Appeals Court Allows Trump Administration’s DEI Crackdown to Proceed, but Judges Debate DEI Merits


A federal appeals court on Friday allowed the Trump administration’s crackdown on diversity, equity and inclusion programs across the federal government to go forward by pausing a lower-court ruling in Maryland that had blocked enforcement of a series of President Trump’s executive orders.

However, the concurring opinions provided by the three judges revealed a sharp political line dividing the jurists on whether diversity was a nonpartisan value of American life or a political philosophy open to scrutiny.

Mr. Trump has made aggressive moves to purge diversity initiatives from the government, and administration officials have threatened federal employees with “adverse consequences” if they fail to report on colleagues who defy the orders. Judge Adam B. Abelson of the District of Maryland had written in the lower court ruling last month that the orders sought to punish people for constitutionally protected speech.

On Friday, the three-judge panel of the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, in Richmond, Va., found that the Trump administration had “satisfied the factors for a stay” of that order, writing that the orders “are of distinctly limited scope” and “do not purport to establish the illegality of all efforts to advance diversity, equity or inclusion.”

Chief Judge Albert Diaz, who was appointed to the Fourth Circuit by President Barack Obama in 2010, wrote that ruling in the Trump administration’s favor was warranted but pushed back against the attacks on diversity initiatives, saying that “people of good faith who work to promote diversity, equity, and inclusion deserve praise, not opprobrium.”

“When this country embraces true diversity, it acknowledges and respects the social identity of its people,” wrote Judge Diaz, who became the first Hispanic jurist to serve as chief judge of the court in 2023. “When it fosters true equity, it opens opportunities and ensures a level playing field for all. And when its policies are truly inclusive, it creates an environment and culture where everyone is respected and valued.”

He continued, “What could be more American than that?”

Judge Pamela Harris, writing in her own concurring opinion, said that she shared Judge Diaz’s sentiment.

“My vote should not be understood as agreement with the orders’ attack on efforts to promote diversity, equity, and inclusion,” wrote Judge Harris, who was also appointed to the court by Mr. Obama.

But Judge Allison Jones Rushing, who was appointed by Mr. Trump during his first term, used her own concurring opinion to criticize Judge Diaz’s declaration of support for diversity, equity and inclusion.

“Any individual judge’s view on whether certain executive action is good policy is not only irrelevant to fulfilling our duty to adjudicate cases and controversies according to the law, it is an impermissible consideration,” Judge Rushing wrote.

She continued, “A judge’s opinion that D.E.I. programs ‘deserve praise, not opprobrium’ should play absolutely no part in deciding this case.”

Umair

Muhammad Umair is a passionate content creator, web developer, and tech enthusiast. With years of experience in developing dynamic websites and curating engaging content, he specializes in delivering accurate, informative, and up-to-date articles across diverse topics. From gaming and technology to crypto and world news, Umair's expertise ensures a seamless blend of technical knowledge and captivating storytelling. When he's not writing or coding, he enjoys gaming and exploring the latest trends in the tech world.

Related Posts

Airman Charged in Killing of Woman Missing Since August

An airman stationed at Ellsworth Air Force Base in South Dakota was charged in the murder of a woman who had been missing since August and was killed on the…

Nita Lowey, Tenacious New York Representative, Dies at 87

Nita M. Lowey, who represented a congressional district based in Westchester County for 32 years, ardently supporting liberal causes and playing a key role in shaping legislation to advance them,…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You Missed

What This Means for the Market

  • By Umair
  • March 16, 2025
  • 1 views
What This Means for the Market

Tom Cruise, Ana de Armas fail to keep secret romance under radar?

  • By Umair
  • March 16, 2025
  • 1 views
Tom Cruise, Ana de Armas fail to keep secret romance under radar?

Bitcoin reclaims $80K zone as BNB, TON, GT, ATOM hint at altcoin season

  • By Umair
  • March 16, 2025
  • 4 views
Bitcoin reclaims $80K zone as BNB, TON, GT, ATOM hint at altcoin season

Airman Charged in Killing of Woman Missing Since August

  • By Umair
  • March 16, 2025
  • 4 views
Airman Charged in Killing of Woman Missing Since August

Mr. Wonderful says the crypto cowboy era is over. Really?

  • By Umair
  • March 16, 2025
  • 5 views
Mr. Wonderful says the crypto cowboy era is over. Really?

40x Leverage, Millions on the Line—Meet the Trader Betting Big Against BTC

  • By Umair
  • March 16, 2025
  • 4 views
40x Leverage, Millions on the Line—Meet the Trader Betting Big Against BTC